Sittercity logo
Sittercity logo
Image of babysitter with children.

Find experienced babysitters in Bay Shore, NY

Last-minute, school and tutoring, date nights—find the right babysitters for you.

Get started

I need a babysitter

256 active babysitters near you

Average rate is $25.43/hr

140,000 5-star parent reviews

Trusted by

  • Good Morning America
  • Today Show
  • The New York Times
  • Washington Post
  • Forbes

Find your babysitter in Bay Shore, NY

Cathy S.

  • 20 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Cathy S., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 20 years of paid experience

I was a Nanny for 6 yrs with the same family..I have a degree in Early Childhood..I have a lot of experience working with special ed children and adults...I also have experience in daycare with infants, toddlers and pre-schoolers and older children.

  • Complete Basic Background Check Badge Icon
  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–25/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Shirkira P.

This was my first time using a babysitter, so I was naturally a little nervous. Cathy made me feel comfortable and reassured me throughout the experience. I really appreciated her kindness and how she helped ease my worries. I had a great experience and would definitely recommend her to other families. I would happily book with Cathy again!

View Profile

Caitlyn J.

  • 12 years paid experience
  • 13 miles
Caitlyn J., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 12 years of paid experience

Hi there! My name is Caitlyn and I have enjoyed working with tiny humans for several years now! I was a nursery school teacher, and have also provided services to children with ASD. I love teaching the tiny minds and creating a playful environment for them to flourish!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–45/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Ayelet H.

Caitlyn was a pleasure to work with! She watched our infant at a family wedding. She was extremely caring and provided a calm environment amidst the excitement of a family celebration. She was flexible and so helpful.

View Profile

Catherine A.

  • 7 years paid experience
  • 13 miles
Catherine A., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 7 years of paid experience

Hi! I wanted to share that I have availability in my schedule to offer private swimming lessons to those 5 & up starting this May! I graduated from Stony Brook with a degree in Psychology, and am currently a full time Nanny during the weekdays- offering this as a weekend activity. I swam Varsity Swimming & Diving throughout my high school years, and have been offering lessons since then. I incorporate a fun, one on one experience, allowing your child to learn throughout a safe, enjoyable course. Lessons are held at clients house. Pricing is as follows: 1 child/30minutes: $50 1 child/ 1hr: $100 2 children/ 1hr (30 minutes each): $100 If you are interested and/or have any questions, please contact me at (631)356-3504

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–30/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Jacqueline R.

Catherine has been working with us for almost a year watching my 16 month old daughter while I work from home. She is extremely reliable and has helped our family tremendously. My daughter is happy to see her when she arrives and I am confident she is getting quality care. Catherine has experience with children in the infant/toddler range and always informs me of updates throughout the day and keeps my little one on schedule. She genuinely seems to enjoy working with kids, engaging in playtime and taking my daughter to activities. She has even taken care of our dog while we've been away. Overall I would recommend her to anyone looking for care for their children.

View Profile

Diane V.

  • 15 years paid experience
  • 7 miles
Diane V., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 15 years of paid experience

I am a fun, happy, dependable, reliable, trustworthy hard worker! I have two associates one in Paralegal Studies and the second in Performing Arts. I am attending Empire State College focusing on Education Degree for my bachelors degree. I love animals, kids and their families as if they were my own. I have been a Babysitter on and off since 2000 to present. Home Care Services caring for cerebral palsy patient and at times her cousins 2014 to 2018. Companion Care USA caring for elderly veteran and at times his grandchildren 2018 to 2019. Summer School Program 2022 in Bay Shore District. Paraprofessional at Bay Shore School District 2021 to 2023. ACDS working with children and their families 2022 to 2025. Currently started my new job working in Brentwood School District 2025-Present via Horizon Staffing Solutions. American Red Cross CPR/AED Certified American Red Cross Babysitting Basic Certified American Red Cross Advanced Child Care Certified

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$15–30/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Marie F.

Diane is so reliable, personable, and genuine! After a couple of years of her picking my daughter up from school to spend time with her at home until we returned from work, she became like family; we still keep in touch. We consider ourselves so fortunate to have found a wonderful person in Diane!

View Profile

Odalie C.

  • 7 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Odalie  C., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 7 years of paid experience

My name is odalie , I have my associates in child study , bachelors in psychology and I’m going for my masters in clinical mental health. I have experience with the age group of newborns up until late teens. I am a person who is reliable & always likes to help others. I have my own transportation and can cook etc..

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$15–20/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Milli P.

Odalie was a fantastic sitter for my 2 year old son and 5 month old daughter. She was on time and connected with the kids immediately, who can be very hard to please at times . She played with them, feed them and put them down for nap time with ease . Wish she was available full time I would have kept her until the kids are ready for school .

View Profile

Alexandra W.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Alexandra W., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 10 years of paid experience

i am active fun and reliable and very trustworthy i have been the family babysitter since i was about 11 i am very mature i have been a babysitter for non family members since 16 and every family been pleased i work well with special needs children as well since i do have a 15 year old sitter that does have special needs, also now I have a 14m old daughter if you are willing to allow mw to bring my child I can work for slightly less pay. I have a truck and library card. Pack up the kids and let’s explore

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–25/hr

View Profile

Caitlin K.

  • 4 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Caitlin K., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 4 years of paid experience

Hi! I’m Caitlin, and I absolutely love working with children and helping them learn, grow, and feel confident. I’ve been babysitting for over 5 years and have been working as a teacher for the past 3 years. I’ve had experience as a lead teacher with toddlers ages 2–3 and children ages 3–4, and I currently work with preschoolers. I’m patient, caring, responsible, and always try to create a fun, safe, and positive environment where children can be themselves. I’d love the opportunity to care for your little ones and give them the same attention and kindness I would want for my own family. I currently have an active heart saver cpr/aed certification for adults and pediatric and training in asthma care along with various certifications taken for my work.

  • Complete Basic Background Check Badge Icon
  • Complete Motor Vehicle Records Check Badge Icon MVR
  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–28/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Nick T.

Caitlin is such a doll and she is fantastic with my kids. I have a boy and a girl 2 & 3 years old. My boy was having trouble potty training and Caitlin did such a good job with him, only took him about a month to get it down. Overall my kids love her and they can’t wait to see her whenever she comes around.

View Profile

Kathy D.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 13 miles
Kathy D., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 10 years of paid experience

Hi, I'm Kathy — a mom of three and former classroom teacher who believes childcare should feel like a partnership with your family, not just a job. I'm currently available for part-time work. Calm, dependable, and always ready to meet your kids where they are. Having raised three children of my own, I understand firsthand what it truly takes to nurture, guide, and show up for a child day after day. Teaching is at the core of how I care for kids. With years of experience as a classroom teacher, I know how to connect with children of all ages, adapt to different learning styles, and meet them exactly where they are — whether that's working through a tricky homework assignment, encouraging a reluctant reader, or simply being patient while working through tantrums. I bring that same structure and attentiveness to every family I work with. As a certified nutrition and health coach, I bring a thoughtful perspective on healthy habits and routines for kids, and my CPR and First Aid certifications give you added confidence that your little ones are in capable hands. Beyond childcare, I'm happy to help with light housekeeping to keep things running smoothly while you're away, and as an animal lover, I'm completely comfortable around pets of all kinds. My goal is to be someone you trust completely — reliable, attentive, and consistent — so you can have real peace of mind while you're away.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$25–35/hr

View Profile

Denisa A.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Denisa A., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 10 years of paid experience

Hello! I'm Denisa. I have been babysitting and housekeeping around Westchester county for 10 year now. I have experienced with newborns, toddler and older children. I have a good reference and experiences with the past families I have been with. Hope to hear from you soon.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$25–35/hr

View Profile

Rori N.

  • 3 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Rori N., Babysitter in Bay Shore, NY 11706 with 3 years of paid experience

Hi my name is Rori! I’m a college student home for the summer looking for some cash while I take classes. I have experience with kids of all ages most recently elementary aged kids.

$22–26/hr

View Profile

Find the sitter you need:

Specialized babysitting services

Bay Shore babysitter FAQ

Find trusted babysitters in Bay Shore today

Caregiver playing with two children
Find your sitter now