Sittercity logo
Sittercity logo
Image of babysitter with children.

Find experienced babysitters in Fishers Island, NY

Last-minute, school and tutoring, date nights—find the right babysitters for you.

Get started

I need a babysitter

74 active babysitters near you

Average rate is $28.10/hr

140,000 5-star parent reviews

Trusted by

  • Good Morning America
  • Today Show
  • The New York Times
  • Washington Post
  • Forbes

Find your babysitter in Fishers Island, NY

Ella T.

  • 4 years paid experience
  • 8 miles
Ella T., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 4 years of paid experience

Hi! My name is Ella, I am 21 and an incoming senior at Connecticut College. I am looking to be a part-time babysitter/nanny this upcoming school year. I have my own car and am available Monday, Wednesday, and Weekends. I absolutely love children and have tons of experience babysitting little ones. I have strong nanny experience with toddlers. I also have lots of experience babysitting bigger families- I have nannied for a family of 3 with an age range of 3 to 9. I love to be outside, active, and creative! I have also completed 100 hours of volunteer work at my college's lab preschool, working with 1 to 3 years old. I have done week week-long overnight sitting as well. I hope to meet you soon!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon

$23–30/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Alexis H.

My daughter absolutely loved Miss.Ella !!!

View Profile

Emily G.

  • 17 years paid experience
  • 15 miles
Emily G., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 17 years of paid experience

I am a 36 year old professional with over 15 years of experience caring for children age 6mos-12yrs. I have a Master's Degree and NYS certification in Childhood Education. I currently keep busy with a daytime management role with availability most evenings after 5pm.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–35/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Sarah F.

Emily was wonderful with our kids. She jumped right in and helped them feel comfortable within minutes of arriving. She also tidied up after them which we really appreciated. We would absolutely hire Emily again!

View Profile

Sophie M.

  • 7 years paid experience
  • 15 miles
Sophie  M., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 7 years of paid experience

Hi! I’m Sophie, a 23-year-old fourth-year medical student from Galway, Ireland, spending my third summer in Montauk! I have over 7 years of childcare experience and have babysat for more than 15 Montauk families, caring for children from 6 months to 12 years old. I’m first aid trained, lifeguard trained, and comfortable supervising children safely at the beach or pool. I also have experience working with children with a range of special needs. As a former gymnastics and hockey coach, I love keeping kids active, engaged, and having fun while always ensuring they feel safe and supported. My goal is to create a warm, playful, and dependable environment where children can thrive and parents can feel completely at ease. I am fully flexible and available throughout the summer, and references are available upon request. Please feel free to message me with any questions—I’d love to hear from you and look forward to meeting your family! 😊🌊☀️

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$35–60/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Kate H.

We hired Sophie during our family vacation in Montauk for the week to help care for our 7-month-old and 5-year-old, and she was wonderful. She was warm, attentive, and clearly experienced with both a baby and a young child at once - no small feat! Our kids adored her, and we felt completely at ease leaving them in her care. She was reliable, communicative, flexible, and went above and beyond to make sure everyone was happy and safe. We’d hire her again in a heartbeat and highly recommend her to any family looking for a trustworthy, caring sitter.

View Profile

Carra W.

  • 7 years paid experience
  • 7 miles
Carra W., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 7 years of paid experience

Hello, I am Jacarra and I love what I do. I currently work at an elementary school and have also worked in daycare settings so I have experience with all ages. Some duties I’ve had over the years included ensuring a safe environment, prepare/serve meals, helped dress children (if needed) I really enjoy arts and crafts, playing outside and going to parks and beaches in the summer time! If they needed medicine, checked on allergies with parents, helped with homework and anything else needed. I currently clean houses so wouldn’t mind tidying up some. If you have any questions feel free to message me!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–30/hr

View Profile

Ellie B.

  • 2 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Ellie B., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 2 years of paid experience

I am a graduating high school senior with almost three years of child care experience! I also have a younger brother that is five years younger than I whom I’ve babysat growing up. I enjoy engaging with his friends playing sports, watching movies, etc… I am going to college for elementary education and have assistant taught at the kindergarten through third grade levels. In the last two years I have babysat for a family with a 1 and 3 year old, as well as a family with a newborn, 3, 4 and 7 year olds. I have a passion for teaching and helping kids grow! I am a patient, creative, and kind person. I am also currently taking a first aid/cpr training class and will be certified in a month. I have experience with diaper changing, doing activities/homework with kids, preparing meals, and I also have a car! I am looking for a summer nannying/babysitting job, please feel free to reach out!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–23/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

elizabeth F.

I had the pleasure of working with Ellie while traveling for work with my two boys (ages 2 and 4), who—like most little ones—can be a bit wild at times. From the very beginning, she gave me confidence by clearly communicating and committing to the timing well in advance, which was incredibly reassuring given the logistics of my trip. Throughout her time with the boys, she remained calm, patient, and attentive. It’s not always easy managing high energy and short attention spans, but she handled them with a steady, caring presence that made all the difference. I could tell she genuinely cared and took the role seriously, which allowed me to focus on my work knowing they were in good hands. I wouldn’t hesitate to call on her again for future care. Highly recommended!

View Profile

Jacarraw W.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 7 miles
Jacarraw W., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 10 years of paid experience

I’m a reliable, patient, and attentive sitter with experience caring for children of all ages, from infants to elementary-aged kids. I genuinely enjoy creating a calm, fun, and structured environment where kids feel safe, engaged, and comfortable being themselves. I’m great at balancing playtime, learning, and routines—whether that’s helping with homework, preparing snacks, or planning creative, screen-free activities. I’m available Monday–Friday and have flexible daytime hours, making me a great fit for families who need consistent, dependable care. Families describe me as organized, trustworthy, and easy to communicate with. I always aim to keep your home running smoothly while making sure your child is happy, supported, and well cared for.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–30/hr

View Profile

Cathy F.

  • 31 years paid experience
  • 14 miles
Cathy F., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 31 years of paid experience

.Hi! My name is Cathy. I am a young-looking and young-acting retired special education teacher . I really miss the kids. I had been an honorary grandmother to a little girl and watched her one day a week from birth to kindergarten. I played with her both inside - playing board games/Legos/card games/Play-Doh, baked, did arts and crafts, watched Disney /educational videos and outside - going to the park,library, playground, children's museums, aquarium, beach. I have experience with infants and have taught grade ranges Kindergarten through high school. I am very friendly, responsible, caring, kind, cheerful, and hard-working. I have watched a 7 year old girl and 9 year old boy for almost a year until they moved , helping them with homework, playing outdoors, and going to parks, the zoo, movies, and kid's fun places. I have taken care of and nurtured a toddler from the time she was 3 months old until 2 years of age. We went on daily outings to the park, library, and children's museum. I have kept a daily journal for parents to enhance communication. I have had several dogs ( golden retrievers) and am pet-friendly. I am very hard-working, reliable, friendly, kind, supportive, and loyal.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$15–20/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Holly P.

Cathy is an amazing care taker for my son. She understands his needs and is very attention to detail with communication and with all of the activities. I highly recommend her. She is prompt and readily available. After her 2 hour interview with both of us chatting away...I felt very comfortable with choosing her.

View Profile

Joann R.

  • 24 years paid experience
  • 13 miles
Joann R., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 24 years of paid experience

I am a mother of one daughter and grandmother of two; I have worked as a professional nanny for many years after working as a legal assistant. I am originally from Washington State and lived in Hawaii as well. I moved to Rhode Island and Connecticut, respectively, in '98. I enjoy children much more than administrative work, hence, I turned to childcare. I have had many long-term commitments, newborns on-up, twin infants in the mix, and special-needs (autistic;) I am blessed to still see the local, former families. (Although I am "seasoned," in age, I encourage prospective families to view me as bringing a grandmotherly-presence to children - able-bodied, yet mature and nurturing, with no personal commitments to conflict with a family's needs.) I am CPR/First Aid/AED certified (a given,) have a squeaky-clean DMV/BCI check and a non-smoker. Infant care: bottle-feedings, solid foods - all down pat... I have a passion for the arts - Broadway show tunes, children love them! I focus on age-appropriate activities, have collected a wealth of craft project archives and I am well-versed in children's literature; I am a Play-Doh goddess, good for the little ones. I am an avid animal-lover and am more than happy to attend to pet care needs. I am open to any questions you may have and references are readily available.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$21–25/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Christine K.

JoAnn was our nanny for 2.5 years. She was a very loving and nurturing caregiver to my twin boys from infancy through the toddler years. She was extremely reliable, and completely committed to us. My boys love her, but we have moved on to preschool. I encourage you to meet JoAnn for yourself.

View Profile

Brooke B.

  • 12 years paid experience
  • 14 miles
Brooke B., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 12 years of paid experience

Hi, I'm Brooke! I have an extensive childcare background as I've been babysitting/worked with children since I was fourteen, totaling at a little over twelve years now. This includes all ages groups from infants to high schoolers, and experience with all ability stages. I currently work in an office environment in New London, and am looking for addition opportunities to connect and support families in the surrounding areas. I love being able to see kids grow, learn, and explore the world around them. Looking forward to meeting with you!

  • Complete Basic Background Check Badge Icon
  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$18–28/hr

View Profile

Carrie R.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 15 miles
Carrie  R., Babysitter in Fishers Island, NY 06390 with 8 years of paid experience

I am an experienced babysitter with over eight years of childcare experience. Working with children has always been something I’ve loved, and it’s what inspired me to pursue a career in education. I’m currently in my first year of a Master’s in Teaching and I am loving it. Over the years, I’ve cared for children of all ages, from infants to school-aged kids. Two summers I was a full-time childminder for three young children under the age of five.

  • Complete Basic Background Check Badge Icon
  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$28–38/hr

View Profile

Find the sitter you need:

Specialized babysitting services

Fishers Island babysitter FAQ

Find trusted babysitters in Fishers Island today

Caregiver playing with two children
Find your sitter now