Sittercity logo
Sittercity logo
A babysitter looking into the eyes of a child she is caring for

Find experienced babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

Last-minute, school and tutoring, date nights—find the right babysitters for you.

Find experienced babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

99 active babysitters near you

Discover local babysitters in Shelter Island. Find the right fit for your family.

Average rate is $30.36/hr

Based on recent Sittercity data from our community of Shelter Island babysitters.

Available babysitters in Shelter Island, NY
Nia C., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 13 years of paid experience

Nia C.

  • 13 years paid experience
  • 9 miles

$ 38–45/hr

Nia C., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 13 years of paid experience
Hello! I’m Nia. I’m a multi-credentialed teacher that enjoys working with and providing support for children of all ages. I have experience in teaching, babysitting, nannying, and creating impactful and fun experiences for all children in my care. Happy to speak further!
Annabelle M., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience

Annabelle M.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 12 miles

$ 22–30/hr

Annabelle M., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Hi! My name is Annabelle and I recently graduated from Saint Mary’s college in South Bend, but am originally from Asheville, NC. I have been babysitting for over eight years. I love kids and truly enjoy babysitting! I am recently CPR and First Aid Certified. I am currently living in Amagansett and h...
Laura O., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience

Laura O.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles

$ 30–35/hr

Laura O., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience
I am a full-time nanny in East Hampton for a 9 month old and a 3 year old. I have lived and worked in East Hampton for 40 years. A retired dental hygienist. References available! Available evenings.
Jenna L., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience

Jenna L.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles

$ 30–40/hr

Jenna L., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience
Hi! My name is Jenna! I am a math and special education teacher at Montauk Public School and currently live in Springs. I am originally from Nassau County and I went to college at Santa Clara University in California. I have worked as a babysitter for years and I have also worked with kids as camp c...
Michelle L., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience

Michelle L.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 4 miles

$ 25–45/hr

Michelle L., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Experienced sitter & former counselor Living on the north fork Passionate about art, design, and nature Retired corporate girlie CPR Certified
Cyd B., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience

Cyd B.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles

$ 20–30/hr

Cyd B., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience
I have experience watching children of all different ages. I have been babysitting and nanny for almost 10+ years now. I am 30 years old and currently going to school to get my Early Childhood Education degree
Sarah M., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience

Sarah M.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 9 miles

$ 30–40/hr

Sarah M., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Hi! I have been babysitting for 8 years. I have worked at a few different summer camps including the Maidstone Club, Hampton Racquet, and Gurneys. I have worked with kids of all ages and I love being active. I’ve played tennis, volleyball and softball since I was 3 years old.
Rachel C., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience

Rachel C.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 9 miles

$ 30–35/hr

Rachel C., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Hi! My name is Rachel and I’m a 28-year-old pediatric nurse. My original training was in the NICU. Looking to nanny children of any ages during the month of August (2-3 days a week)! Also looking for occasional date-night babysitting jobs. CPR certified.
Tonia R., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 4 years of paid experience

Tonia R.

  • 4 years paid experience
  • 9 miles

$ 30–40/hr

Tonia R., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 4 years of paid experience
I am a recent college graduate, looking for an occasional evening weekend job. I grew up with a big family and have always been like a second mom to my brothers. Love to spend time with babies and kids and help them develop. Responsible and dedicated worker with lots of love to give.
Rebecca F., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 4 years of paid experience

Rebecca F.

  • 4 years paid experience
  • 12 miles

$ 25–40/hr

Rebecca F., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 4 years of paid experience
Hi there, I’m Rebecca! I am Class of 2027 at Skidmore College and have been babysitting in the Hamptons for 5+ years. I’m located in Amagansett during the summer but can travel outside! I am currently majoring in Education with a focus on early childhood while on track to get a NY K-6 certification....

Find the sitter you need:

  • Date night babysitters
  • Daytime babysitters
  • Last-minute care
  • Mother's helpers
  • Newborn care
  • Infant care
  • CPR training
  • First aid training

Babysitting FAQs