Sittercity logo
Sittercity logo
Image of babysitter with children.

Find experienced babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

Last-minute, school and tutoring, date nights—find the right babysitters for you.

Get started

I need a babysitter

78 active babysitters near you

Average rate is $30.39/hr

140,000 5-star parent reviews

Trusted by

  • Good Morning America
  • Today Show
  • The New York Times
  • Washington Post
  • Forbes

Find your babysitter in Shelter Island, NY

Tonia R.

  • 4 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Tonia R., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 4 years of paid experience

I am a recent college graduate, looking for an occasional evening weekend job. I grew up with a big family and have always been like a second mom to my brothers. Love to spend time with babies and kids and help them develop. Responsible and dedicated worker with lots of love to give.

$30–40/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Caroline G.

Tonia was great. She was sweet with my kids and was always on time.

View Profile

Maude M.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Maude M., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience

Local children’s librarian who would love to help your family! I am a mom of two adult children and NYS teacher certified in Early Childhood/Elementary Education and Reading/Writing Birth-6th grades. I work as a local Hamptons children’s librarian and I love to read and do art and STEM projects with kids. CPR and AED certified. I live in East Hampton year-round and grew up in Manhattan.

  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$35–80/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

omer R.

She was very communicative and always on time. Very recommended her.

View Profile

Valentina A.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 3 miles
Valentina A., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience

Hello! I am Valentina! I am a responsible, friendly, creative, reliable nanny. 🩷 I have experience caring for infants, toddlers & elementary age.😊🦋 I was also an elementary substitute teacher 👩🏻‍🏫🌸🎨 I enjoy painting, reading, dance and walks! I am mostly available part time or for families with flexible schedules & occasional date nights. 📆✨

$25–35/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Noemie R.

We had an amazing experience with Valentina, who cared for our 1-year-old. She was attentive, patient, and incredibly nurturing. Our little one immediately warmed up to her, and we were impressed by how well she handled everything—from playtime to feeding and nap time. Valentina followed our instructions perfectly and kept us updated throughout the day, which gave us peace of mind. It’s clear she loves working with children and knows how to engage and comfort them. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a reliable and caring babysitter!

View Profile

Annabelle M.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Annabelle M., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience

Hi! My name is Annabelle and I recently graduated from Saint Mary’s college in South Bend, but am originally from Asheville, NC. I have been babysitting for over eight years. I love kids and truly enjoy babysitting! I am recently CPR and First Aid Certified. I am currently living in Amagansett and have my own transportation. Happy to provide references and talk further!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$22–30/hr

View Profile

Riley H.

  • 6 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Riley H., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 6 years of paid experience

I am a third-year student at the University of Virginia. I am also studying Education and Human Development so I am working with kids in school currently for my practicum hours. I have been babysitting for about 6 years now and I enjoy hanging out with kids as I am one of four kids in my family. I am okay with being in the same house as pets, doing some light house cleaning, prepping dinner, and driving kids if needed.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$15–20/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Cindy E.

Riley was very attentive and responsible! We will definitely ask her to babysit again !

View Profile

Jane S.

  • 3 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Jane S., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 3 years of paid experience

Hi! I’m Jane, a recent graduate from Southern Methodist University with years of childcare and tutoring experience. I grew up in New York City and spent high school afternoons caring for children ages 4 to 12, helping with everything from reading and homework to creative play and crafts. I’m responsible, warm, and intuitive with kids, and I know how to keep a household running smoothly. I’m CPR and first aid certified, great with pets, and happy to assist with light tidying, errands, or organizing if needed. Whether your family needs structure or flexibility, I’m able to create a calm, safe, and engaging environment tailored to your home.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$25–40/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Eli K.

Jane was amazing in all respects. We really look forward to working with her again for both our kids.

View Profile

Laura O.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Laura O., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience

I am a full-time nanny in East Hampton for a 9 month old and a 3 year old. I have lived and worked in East Hampton for 40 years. A retired dental hygienist. References available! Available evenings.

  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–35/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Nicole A.

Laura was a great help during our stay in the Hamptons! She watched our 4 month old and 2 year old at night while we went out. She was very nice and trustworthy and we wish we could use her again back home. I definitely recommend Laura and will be reaching out again when we’re back next year!

View Profile

Olivia B.

  • 5 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Olivia B., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 5 years of paid experience

Hi. I’m a Developmental Psychology major at UC Berkeley with a passion for creating engaging, active, and educational environments for children. My caregiving style combines my academic background in child development with my professional experiences as a former enrichment teacher and youth soccer coach for a top program in Los Angeles. Whatever your child may need, I bring a high level of energy, safety, and intentionality to every day. Safety Credentials: I am CPR & First Aid Certified (Infant, Child, & Adult) AED Certified Rates: 1 Child: $32/ hour 2 Children: $35/ hour 3 Children: $38/ hour

  • Complete Basic Background Check Badge Icon
  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$32–38/hr

View Profile

Juliette P.

  • 3 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Juliette P., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 3 years of paid experience

Hi! I’d describe myself as patient, fun, creative, and dependable. I’ve spent years working with kids throughout high school and college, and as an older sister myself, I understand family and sibling dynamics very well. I genuinely enjoy being around children and love creating a safe, positive, and engaging environment where they can feel comfortable and have fun. Whether it’s helping with routines, keeping kids entertained, or simply being someone parents can rely on, I always try to bring a calm and caring energy. I’m looking for a babysitting position where I can be helpful, supportive, and build a strong relationship with the family I work with. In my free time, I enjoy playing tennis and spending time with my family and friends

  • Complete Basic Background Check Badge Icon
  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$22–25/hr

View Profile

Haley D.

  • 20 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Haley D., Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 20 years of paid experience

Hi, my name is Haley! I grew up in a very nice neighborhood full of families who babysat me and once I became of age, I babysat their kids which began my 20 years of sitter experience . I learned early on how much I love being around kids, and creating engaging, fun, and educational activities for them. During my time in highschool, I was a camp head counselor and babysat several families, many of whom I still help out occasionally. I have experience with children of all ages, including infants, as well as families that have multiple kids. In the summer during COVID, when camps were closed, a friend and I organized our own personalized camp for nine kids who had spent quarantine together. We came up with great ways to spend each day and stay active, making it a memorable summer for everyone. I always try to figure out the best way I can connect with your child so they will feel comfortable with me right away. I hope I’m a good match for you and your family!

  • Complete Basic Background Check Badge Icon
  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$25–40/hr

View Profile

Find the sitter you need:

Specialized babysitting services

Shelter Island babysitter FAQ

Find trusted babysitters in Shelter Island today

Caregiver playing with two children
Find your sitter now