Sittercity logo
Sittercity logo
Image of babysitter with children.

Find experienced nannies in Shelter Island, NY

Last-minute, school and tutoring, date nights—find the right babysitters for you.

Get started

I need a nanny

32 active nannies near you

Average rate is $29.85/hr

140,000 5-star parent reviews

Trusted by

  • Good Morning America
  • Today Show
  • The New York Times
  • Washington Post
  • Forbes

Find your nanny in Shelter Island, NY

Cory B.

  • 15 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Cory B., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 15 years of paid experience

I am a devoted and organized nanny with over ten years of experience. My expertise is in providing loving care and to ensure disciplinary and educational goals are met for each child in my care. I also love to have fun, laugh, and be active! Happiness is a priority in my life :). My expertise in childcare offers children clear guidelines that promote healthy and positive behavior patterns while enjoying life at the same time!

$20–40/hr

View Profile

Odalys B.

  • 9 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Odalys B., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 9 years of paid experience

My name is Odalys Bonilla I am 26 years old. I have 9 years of experience as a babysitter. I have 2 children of my own, my boy is 5 and my girl is 4 years. I also have my own car and a clean driving record. I am very loving, patient and outgoing. Babysitting is something I love doing because everyday is different and new and it’s amazing being part of a child learning and growing as a person. I look forward to hearing from you.

$30–45/hr

View Profile

Annabelle M.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Annabelle M., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 8 years of paid experience

Hi! My name is Annabelle and I recently graduated from Saint Mary’s college in South Bend, but am originally from Asheville, NC. I have been babysitting for over eight years. I love kids and truly enjoy babysitting! I am recently CPR and First Aid Certified. I am currently living in Amagansett and have my own transportation. Happy to provide references and talk further!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$25–35/hr

View Profile

Riley H.

  • 6 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Riley H., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 6 years of paid experience

I am a third-year student at the University of Virginia. I am also studying Education and Human Development so I am working with kids in school currently for my practicum hours. I have been babysitting for about 6 years now and I enjoy hanging out with kids as I am one of four kids in my family. I am okay with being in the same house as pets, doing some light house cleaning, prepping dinner, and driving kids if needed.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$25–35/hr

View Profile

Laura O.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Laura O., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience

I am a full-time nanny in East Hampton for a 9 month old and a 3 year old. I have lived and worked in East Hampton for 40 years. A retired dental hygienist. References available! Available evenings.

  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–35/hr

View Profile

Ana S.

  • 5 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Ana S., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 5 years of paid experience

hello, my name is Ana Santiago I am nineteen years old. I love being around kids and taking care of them. I have ben taking care of kids and older people from a young age, because I love helping others that's why mu major is nursing. I am bilingual. if you choose me you wont regret it . thank you.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–25/hr

View Profile

Cyd B.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Cyd B., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience

I have experience watching children of all different ages. I have been babysitting and nanny for almost 10+ years now. I am 30 years old and currently going to school to get my Early Childhood Education degree

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–30/hr

View Profile

Rebecca F.

  • 4 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Rebecca F., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 4 years of paid experience

Hi there, I’m Rebecca! I am Class of 2027 at Skidmore College and have been babysitting in the Hamptons for 5+ years. I’m located in Amagansett during the summer but can travel outside! I am currently majoring in Education with a focus on early childhood while on track to get a NY K-6 teaching certification. I have worked at a Daycare on campus caring for children ages 2 months to 5 years old. I have completed the State mandated training requirements that are in child care regulations(Foundations in Health and Learning) and had my fingerprints/ background check done by the state of New York. I’ve also completed all workshops necessary for the NY teaching certification. My goal after graduation is to become a preschool or daycare teacher (although elementary age is growing on me). I love taking care of kids; hanging out with them, playing games, and figuring out fun things to do (whether it's a dance contest or the floor has turned to lava!). I also love hanging with infants and watching their developments and being able to positively assist in their growth into functional human beings! I can cook and clean as well as take care of/watch any pets. I have been trained in CPR as well as water safety. I find babysitting fun and rewarding, I look forward to meeting everyone!!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$25–50/hr

View Profile

Sifundo N.

  • 5 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Sifundo N., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 5 years of paid experience

Dear Family, My name is Sifundo, but everyone calls me Siffy. I am reaching out to express my interest in a full-time childcare position in the Westchester area. I am also open to a live-in arrangement for the right family, particularly if the position is farther from my home. I am a nursing student with over six years of hands-on experience caring for children of all ages—from toddlers to teenagers. Caring for children is not just something I do; it is something I genuinely love. I bring a calm, attentive, and positive presence into a home, whether we are playing, reading, supporting homework, or sharing quiet moments together. I approach childcare with intention, prioritizing safety, emotional well-being, structure, and fun. Families often describe me as nurturing, dependable, and intuitive with children. My goal is always to create an environment where children feel secure, supported, and encouraged to be themselves. As a nursing student, I bring an added level of responsibility, attentiveness, and care to my work. I am reliable, flexible, and respectful of family routines and values. I understand the trust required when welcoming someone into your home and take that responsibility very seriously. I am seeking a long-term, full-time role where I can be a consistent and supportive presence for a family. I would love the opportunity to connect, learn more about your needs, and see if we might be a great fit. Thank you very much for your time and consideration. I look forward to hearing from you. Warm regards, Sifundo “Siffy” Nene 📧 sibongilenene23@gmail.com 📞 914-374-4643

  • Complete Basic Background Check Badge Icon
  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–35/hr

View Profile

Jenna L.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Jenna L., Nanny in Shelter Island, NY 11964 with 10 years of paid experience

Hi! My name is Jenna! I am a math and special education teacher at Montauk Public School and currently live in Springs. I am originally from Nassau County and I went to college at Santa Clara University in California. I have worked as a babysitter for years and I have also worked with kids as camp counselor. In my free time I like to cook (would love to cook for your family) and run! I am looking for night time babysitting jobs.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–40/hr

View Profile

Find the nanny services you need:

  • In-Home nannies
  • Full-time nannies
  • Part-time nannies
  • Live-in nannies
  • Summer nannies
  • Nanny housekeepers
  • Mother's helper
  • College nannies
  • CPR training
  • First aid training

Shelter Island nanny FAQ

Find trusted nannies in Shelter Island today

Caregiver playing with two children
Find your nanny now