Find experienced nannies in Shelter Island, NY
Last-minute, school and tutoring, date nights—find the right babysitters for you.
Get started
I need a nanny
35 active nannies near you
Average rate is $30.93/hr
140,000 5-star parent reviews
Trusted by
Find your nanny in Shelter Island, NY
Cory B.
- 15 years paid experience
- 12 miles
I am a devoted and organized nanny with over ten years of experience. My expertise is in providing loving care and to ensure disciplinary and educational goals are met for each child in my care. I also love to have fun, laugh, and be active! Happiness is a priority in my life :). My expertise in childcare offers children clear guidelines that promote healthy and positive behavior patterns while enjoying life at the same time!
$20–40/hr
Recent review:
5.0
Jennifer F.
I highly recommend Cory! I hired Cory to babysit for two nights while my family was out in Cutchogue. We had a baby sleeping, and then Cory took care of 9 year old and 6 year old girls. The girls loved playing and reading with her. Although we didn't spend too much time with Cory, I could tell she was really caring and would be able to take care of the baby if need be. I'll definitely hire Cory again when we are out on the North Fork!
Odalys B.
- 9 years paid experience
- 9 miles
My name is Odalys Bonilla I am 26 years old. I have 9 years of experience as a babysitter. I have 2 children of my own, my boy is 5 and my girl is 4 years. I also have my own car and a clean driving record. I am very loving, patient and outgoing. Babysitting is something I love doing because everyday is different and new and it’s amazing being part of a child learning and growing as a person. I look forward to hearing from you.
$30–45/hr
Recent review:
5.0
Rob P.
Odalys is so so dependable and fantastic with children. She took care of our 4 month old boy as though he was her own. Do not hesitate to hire Odalys.
Annabelle M.
- 8 years paid experience
- 12 miles
Hi! My name is Annabelle and I recently graduated from Saint Mary’s college in South Bend, but am originally from Asheville, NC. I have been babysitting for over eight years. I love kids and truly enjoy babysitting! I am recently CPR and First Aid Certified. I am currently living in Amagansett and have my own transportation. Happy to provide references and talk further!
$25–35/hr
Cyd B.
- 10 years paid experience
- 9 miles
I have experience watching children of all different ages. I have been babysitting and nanny for almost 10+ years now. I am 30 years old and currently going to school to get my Early Childhood Education degree
$20–30/hr
Jahlia N.
- 11 years paid experience
- 12 miles
Hi! My name is Jahlia, I’m 26 years old, and I have been working with children for over a decade. My childcare journey began in high school as a camp counselor at S.T.A.R., and from that moment on I knew my passion was creating a safe, engaging, and supportive space where children can learn, explore, and grow. I am bilingual in English and Spanish and graduated from the Dual Language Program at Southampton High School. I also studied Early Childhood Development at Suffolk Community College, gaining foundational knowledge that I’ve applied throughout my hands-on experience. After high school, I nannied full-time through a nanny platform before moving into school-based positions. I worked at Alternatives for Children as a part-time secretary, where I supported children with mild to severe intellectual and behavioral disabilities and assisted in classrooms and parent–teacher conference translations. I later became a part-time school monitor and translator at Tuckahoe School District. From there, I accepted a Teacher’s Aide position at Wunnechaunuck Shinnecock Preschool working with infants ages 6 weeks to 18 months. I am currently collaborating with a teacher at Southampton School District to create a nonprofit organization focused on providing camps, workshops, and enrichment opportunities for children of all ages. I have a valid driver’s license and reliable transportation (a spacious 2013 Ford Flex with room for car seats, strollers, and third-row seating). I love taking children to the library, parks, children’s museums, and after-school activities. I’m happy to share references, parent reviews, and samples of the educational curriculums I’ve created. I would love the opportunity to support your family and provide safe, nurturing, and reliable care for your child.
$20–50/hr
Michelle L.
- 8 years paid experience
- 4 miles
Hey there! My name is Michelle I have more than 10 years of child care experience and have some upcoming weekend availability! Fully licensed, First Aid & CPR certified. I am the perfect date night sitter - so if you have an upcoming event please feel free to reach out! *References upon request* Best, Michelle
$25–35/hr
Jenna L.
- 10 years paid experience
- 9 miles
Hi! My name is Jenna! I am a math and special education teacher at Montauk Public School and currently live in Springs. I am originally from Nassau County and I went to college at Santa Clara University in California. I have worked as a babysitter for years and I have also worked with kids as camp counselor. In my free time I like to cook (would love to cook for your family) and run! I am looking for night time babysitting jobs.
$30–40/hr
Sifundo N.
- 5 years paid experience
- 12 miles
Dear Family, My name is Sifundo, but everyone calls me Siffy. I am reaching out to express my interest in a full-time childcare position in the Westchester area. I am also open to a live-in arrangement for the right family, particularly if the position is farther from my home. I am a nursing student with over six years of hands-on experience caring for children of all ages—from toddlers to teenagers. Caring for children is not just something I do; it is something I genuinely love. I bring a calm, attentive, and positive presence into a home, whether we are playing, reading, supporting homework, or sharing quiet moments together. I approach childcare with intention, prioritizing safety, emotional well-being, structure, and fun. Families often describe me as nurturing, dependable, and intuitive with children. My goal is always to create an environment where children feel secure, supported, and encouraged to be themselves. As a nursing student, I bring an added level of responsibility, attentiveness, and care to my work. I am reliable, flexible, and respectful of family routines and values. I understand the trust required when welcoming someone into your home and take that responsibility very seriously. I am seeking a long-term, full-time role where I can be a consistent and supportive presence for a family. I would love the opportunity to connect, learn more about your needs, and see if we might be a great fit. Thank you very much for your time and consideration. I look forward to hearing from you. Warm regards, Sifundo “Siffy” Nene 📧 sibongilenene23@gmail.com 📞 914-374-4643
$30–35/hr
Ella A.
- 5 years paid experience
- 9 miles
Hello! My name is Ella, and I'm so excited to take on the opportunity to become an au pair/babysitter/nanny. I am looking for a welcoming family that will treat me as one of their own, and in return, I hope to become a trusted and supportive, part of their lives. I currently have CPR Certification along with First aid. I am graduating from high school this June with a 4.0 GPA. Before pursuing my goal of attending flight school and becoming an airline pilot, I would love the opportunity to become an au pair, experience a new culture, and create memories while supporting a host family. Currently, I work at my local airport's fixed-base operator (FBO), where I assist with daily operations and customer service. Alongside my job, I regularly help a local family by picking up their child from school and caring for them until their parents finish work. I am graduating from high school this June with a 4.0 GPA. Before pursuing my goal of attending flight school and becoming an airline pilot, I would love the opportunity to become an au pair, experience a new culture, and create memories while supporting a host family. Currently, I work at my local airport's fixed-base operator (FBO), where I assist with daily operations and ramp access. Alongside my job, I regularly help a local family by picking up their child from school and caring for them until their parents finish work. Childcare has been a consistent part of my life for several years. Over the past two summers, I have worked with two different families, helping care for their children and assisting with daily routines and activities. In addition, I frequently babysit for family friends and my younger cousins. I look forward to helping with whatever your family may need while also learning about a new culture and sharing my own. One of the things I enjoy most about working with children is watching them learn, grow, and develop into their own unique individuals. I love encouraging their creativity, confidence. I would describe myself as responsible, positive, outgoing, and dependable. I am also patient, adaptable, and easygoing, which allows me to adjust well to new situations and routines. I have a "go with the flow" personality and enjoy approaching life with an open mind and positive attitude. Along with that I love traveling. I am willing to travel anywhere you may need me! Can’t wait to connect with a family soon!
$30–55/hr
Caoimhe M.
- 10 years paid experience
- 9 miles
Hi! I am a current teacher here in Charlotte. Our school year will be ending this week and I do not start my summer tutoring/ teaching job until July. If you are looking for help for the month of June, let’s chat! I have a MA in Early childhood education and a BA in Early Childhood development. Beyond teaching I have worked as a nanny for 4 years. The last family I worked for I started when the boys were 4months and 5yo and I worked with them until this past summer when they were 2 and 7. I love working with children and families, so please reach out if I can help!
$20–35/hr
Find the nanny services you need:
- In-Home nannies
- Full-time nannies
- Part-time nannies
- Live-in nannies
- Summer nannies
- Nanny housekeepers
- Mother's helper
- College nannies
- CPR training
- First aid training
School help
Shelter Island nanny FAQ
Find trusted nannies in Shelter Island today