
Find experienced babysitters in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Last-minute, school and tutoring, date nights—find the right babysitters for you.
Find experienced babysitters in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Get started: tell us about your needs
Regular
Weekly, before/after school, driving
Occasional
As-needed for when you need care
One time
Date night, upcoming event, backup
99 active babysitters near you
Discover local babysitters in Shelter Island Heights. Find the right fit for your family.
Average rate is $30.36/hr
Based on recent Sittercity data from our community of Shelter Island Heights babysitters.

Cyd B.
- 10 years paid experience
- 10 miles
$ 20–30/hr


Nia C.
- 13 years paid experience
- 10 miles
$ 38–45/hr


Ana S.
- 5 years paid experience
- 10 miles
$ 10–25/hr

Carroll L.
- 28 years paid experience
- 10 miles
$ 25–30/hr

Odalys B.
- 9 years paid experience
- 10 miles
$ 30–45/hr


Laura O.
- 10 years paid experience
- 10 miles
$ 30–35/hr


Tonia R.
- 4 years paid experience
- 10 miles
$ 30–40/hr


Rebecca F.
- 4 years paid experience
- 13 miles
$ 25–40/hr


Annabelle M.
- 8 years paid experience
- 13 miles
$ 22–30/hr


Maude M.
- 10 years paid experience
- 10 miles
$ 35–80/hr

Find the sitter you need:
- Date night babysitters
- Daytime babysitters
- Last-minute care
- Mother's helpers
- Newborn care
- Infant care
- CPR training
- First aid training