Sittercity logo
Sittercity logo
Image of babysitter with children.

Find experienced nannies in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Last-minute, school and tutoring, date nights—find the right babysitters for you.

Get started

I need a nanny

27 active nannies near you

Average rate is $31.12/hr

140,000 5-star parent reviews

Trusted by

  • Good Morning America
  • Today Show
  • The New York Times
  • Washington Post
  • Forbes

Find your nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Cory B.

  • 15 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Cory B., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 15 years of paid experience

I am a devoted and organized nanny with over ten years of experience. My expertise is in providing loving care and to ensure disciplinary and educational goals are met for each child in my care. I also love to have fun, laugh, and be active! Happiness is a priority in my life :). My expertise in childcare offers children clear guidelines that promote healthy and positive behavior patterns while enjoying life at the same time!

$20–40/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Jennifer F.

I highly recommend Cory! I hired Cory to babysit for two nights while my family was out in Cutchogue. We had a baby sleeping, and then Cory took care of 9 year old and 6 year old girls. The girls loved playing and reading with her. Although we didn't spend too much time with Cory, I could tell she was really caring and would be able to take care of the baby if need be. I'll definitely hire Cory again when we are out on the North Fork!

View Profile

Valentina A.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 2 miles
Valentina A., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 8 years of paid experience

Hello! I am Valentina! I am a responsible, friendly, creative, reliable nanny. 🩷 I have experience caring for infants, toddlers & elementary age.😊🦋 I was also an elementary substitute teacher 👩🏻‍🏫🌸🎨 I enjoy painting, reading, dance and walks! I am mostly available part time or for families with flexible schedules & occasional date nights. 📆✨

$30–40/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Noemie R.

We had an amazing experience with Valentina, who cared for our 1-year-old. She was attentive, patient, and incredibly nurturing. Our little one immediately warmed up to her, and we were impressed by how well she handled everything—from playtime to feeding and nap time. Valentina followed our instructions perfectly and kept us updated throughout the day, which gave us peace of mind. It’s clear she loves working with children and knows how to engage and comfort them. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a reliable and caring babysitter!

View Profile

Sylwia G.

  • 15 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Sylwia G., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 15 years of paid experience

Hi! I’m a professional nanny and Newborn Care Specialist with over 10 years of experience caring for children from newborns through teens. I’m CPR and First Aid certified, calm, reliable, and someone families turn to when they need a safe extra set of hands. I know the Hamptons well, I’m local, I drive, I swim, and I love spending time outside with kids. Whether we’re exploring a nature trail, heading to the beach, or just reading books at home, I love helping children feel calm, confident, and curious. I’m happy to step in wherever I’m needed, and I’m someone who takes initiative and handles things without being asked twice. If you’re looking for someone kind, capable, and close by, I’d love to support your family this summer.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–40/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Merritt T.

Sylwia is a great asset to any family! She was incredible with my baby boy... she's very engaging and she is extremely well-versed in child development. Sylwia is extremely reliable and I would thoroughly recommend her!

View Profile

Annabelle M.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 13 miles
Annabelle M., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 8 years of paid experience

Hi! My name is Annabelle and I recently graduated from Saint Mary’s college in South Bend, but am originally from Asheville, NC. I have been babysitting for over eight years. I love kids and truly enjoy babysitting! I am recently CPR and First Aid Certified. I am currently living in Amagansett and have my own transportation. Happy to provide references and talk further!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$25–35/hr

View Profile

Ana S.

  • 5 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Ana S., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 5 years of paid experience

hello, my name is Ana Santiago I am nineteen years old. I love being around kids and taking care of them. I have ben taking care of kids and older people from a young age, because I love helping others that's why mu major is nursing. I am bilingual. if you choose me you wont regret it . thank you.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–25/hr

Recent review:

Rating star icon

5.0

Catherine J.

Ana is a very talented, nurturing caregiver - my toddler daughter adores her.

View Profile

Jennifer B.

  • 4 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Jennifer B., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 4 years of paid experience

Hi there! My name is Jenn, and I'm a rising senior at SUNY Geneseo. I've been an active caregiver for the past 4+ years, caring for children ages 6 months to 12 years old. I'm a mature, responsible, & trustworthy person who is very motivated, energetic, & an excellent communicator with both parents & children. I adore working with children & teaching them all they need to know in the early stages of their lives and keeping them active, involved, and happy. I am naturally tidy and do not mind pitching in where needed to help the household run smoothly. I am CPR/First Aid certified (pediatric and adult) by the American Red Cross and speak Spanish fluently. With all my skills and experience, I know I am more than able to provide a supervised, safe, stable, and fun environment for your little ones and, more importantly, become a reliable and supportive member of your family.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–30/hr

View Profile

Silvia H.

  • 12 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Silvia  H., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 12 years of paid experience

I truly love working with young kids, and I approach each child as an individual who I get to help grow and teach. I love sports and beach days. Holistic activities and arts.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$35–100/hr

View Profile

Jenna L.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Jenna L., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 10 years of paid experience

Hi! My name is Jenna! I am a math and special education teacher at Montauk Public School and currently live in Springs. I am originally from Nassau County and I went to college at Santa Clara University in California. I have worked as a babysitter for years and I have also worked with kids as camp counselor. In my free time I like to cook (would love to cook for your family) and run! I am looking for night time babysitting jobs.

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–40/hr

View Profile

Katie P.

  • 5 years paid experience
  • 3 miles
Katie P., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 5 years of paid experience

Hi! I'm Katie, a caring and dependable nanny with 5+ years of experience working with children of all ages including newborns. I'm CPR/First Aid certified and have a degree in Health Sciences. I focus on creating a safe, fun, and nurturing environment. I'm happy to help with routines, light housekeeping, errands, and educational activities. I look forward to speaking with you!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$30–45/hr

View Profile

Caoimhe M.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 10 miles
Caoimhe M., Nanny in Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 with 10 years of paid experience

Hi! I am a current teacher here in Charlotte. Our school year will be ending this week and I do not start my summer tutoring/ teaching job until July. If you are looking for help for the month of June, let’s chat! I have a MA in Early childhood education and a BA in Early Childhood development. Beyond teaching I have worked as a nanny for 4 years. The last family I worked for I started when the boys were 4months and 5yo and I worked with them until this past summer when they were 2 and 7. I love working with children and families, so please reach out if I can help!

  • Complete First Aid Training Badge Icon
  • Complete CPR Certification Badge Icon

$20–35/hr

View Profile

Find the nanny services you need:

  • In-Home nannies
  • Full-time nannies
  • Part-time nannies
  • Live-in nannies
  • Summer nannies
  • Nanny housekeepers
  • Mother's helper
  • College nannies
  • CPR training
  • First aid training

Shelter Island Heights nanny FAQ

Find trusted nannies in Shelter Island Heights today

Caregiver playing with two children
Find your nanny now