Sittercity logo
Sittercity logo
babysitter putting an infant into their crib

Looking for some overnight babysitting care in Shelter Island, NY?

Finding overnight care doesn't have to be complicated. Post your care needs to start talking to babysitting specialists now.

Find overnight care

Your babysitter search made simple

Overnight babysitters near Shelter Island

Maude M.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Maude M., Babysitter in 11964 with 10 years of paid experience
Local children’s librarian who would love to help your family! I am a mom of two adult children and NYS teacher cer...

Michelle L.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 4 miles
Michelle L., Babysitter in 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Experienced sitter & former counselor Living on the north fork Passionate about art, design, and nature Retired ...

Kristin D.

  • 16 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Kristin D., Babysitter in 11964 with 16 years of paid experience
Most organized person ever! I have always loved working with children as they bring me much joy. I have been babysi...

Rachel P.

  • 6 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Rachel P., Babysitter in 11964 with 6 years of paid experience
Compassionate experienced supportive reliable nanny for families and children in the Hamptons for 10yrs plus. known...

Sarah M.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Sarah M., Babysitter in 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Hi! I have been babysitting for 8 years. I have worked at a few different summer camps including the Maidstone Club...

Rovitt B.

  • 5 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Rovitt B., Babysitter in 11964 with 5 years of paid experience
Hello! I graduated with my Bachelors in Criminal Justice. I have three amazing siblings all younger then me that I ...

Colleen M.

  • 20 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Colleen M., Babysitter in 11964 with 20 years of paid experience
My name is Colleen McGuire. I am warm, caring , patient, and a lot of fun. I have been babysitting since I was 1...

Ally C.

  • 5 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Ally  C., Babysitter in 11964 with 5 years of paid experience
Hi there, my name is Ally I’m 23 I really enjoy babysitting because I find it incredibly rewarding to connect with ...

Victoria E.

  • 45 years paid experience
  • < 1 mile
Victoria E., Babysitter in 11964 with 45 years of paid experience
I am a former violin/music teacher, pre-school through high school, and the mom of three young adults. I have both ...

Haley D.

  • 20 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Haley D., Babysitter in 11964 with 20 years of paid experience
Hi, my name is Haley! I grew up in a very nice neighborhood full of families who babysat me and once I became of ag...

Connect with professional babysitters on Sittercity to help with your overnight child care needs:

Use our search to browse detailed profiles, ratings, and read reviews from other families. Plus, secured messaging, professional references, interview booking, and more to find what you need.

  • Dinner
  • Date night
  • Bedtime routines
  • Entertainment and play

Common FAQ