Sittercity logo
Sittercity logo
babysitter putting an infant into their crib

Looking for some overnight babysitting care in Shelter Island, NY?

Finding overnight care doesn't have to be complicated. Post your care needs to start talking to babysitting specialists now.

Find overnight care

Your babysitter search made simple

Overnight babysitters near Shelter Island

Haley D.

  • 20 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Haley D., Babysitter in 11964 with 20 years of paid experience
Hi, my name is Haley! I grew up in a very nice neighborhood full of families who babysat me and once I became of ag...

Annabelle M.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Annabelle M., Babysitter in 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Hi! My name is Annabelle and I recently graduated from Saint Mary’s college in South Bend, but am originally from A...

Erin C.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Erin C., Babysitter in 11964 with 10 years of paid experience
My name is Erin, I am 25 with a bachelors degree in PR. I have worked In childcare for 10 years and have worked wit...

Sarah M.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Sarah M., Babysitter in 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Hi! I have been babysitting for 8 years. I have worked at a few different summer camps including the Maidstone Club...

Rovitt B.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Rovitt B., Babysitter in 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Hi! My name is Ruby and I’m a reliable and caring babysitter with more than 6 years of experience working with chil...

Jenna L.

  • 10 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Jenna L., Babysitter in 11964 with 10 years of paid experience
Hi! My name is Jenna! I am a math and special education teacher at Montauk Public School and currently live in Spri...

Odalys B.

  • 9 years paid experience
  • 9 miles
Odalys B., Babysitter in 11964 with 9 years of paid experience
My name is Odalys Bonilla I am 26 years old. I have 9 years of experience as a babysitter. I have 2 children of m...

Sifundo N.

  • 5 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Sifundo N., Babysitter in 11964 with 5 years of paid experience
Dear Family, My name is Sifundo, but everyone calls me Siffy. I am reaching out to express my interest in a fu...

Erica P.

  • 8 years paid experience
  • 8 miles
Erica P., Babysitter in 11964 with 8 years of paid experience
Hi! My name is Erica Parker. I am 30 years old and currently a speech language pathologist full time at an elementa...

Jane S.

  • 3 years paid experience
  • 12 miles
Jane S., Babysitter in 11964 with 3 years of paid experience
Hi! I’m Jane, a recent graduate from Southern Methodist University with years of childcare and tutoring experience....

Connect with professional babysitters on Sittercity to help with your overnight child care needs:

Use our search to browse detailed profiles, ratings, and read reviews from other families. Plus, secured messaging, professional references, interview booking, and more to find what you need.

  • Dinner
  • Date night
  • Bedtime routines
  • Entertainment and play

Common FAQ